Skip to content
Hemingway Room at Old Carrabelle Hotel

Our Reviews

The Old Carrabelle Hotel

Check out what our past guests have to say about us!

"This beautiful hotel in the quaint and quirky town of Carrabelle is fantastic. Each of the bed rooms is artfully & skillfully decorated to perfection. All the fixtures & fittings are high end with all the usual necessities supplied. Everything from the several fluffy towels and beautiful bed linens to shampoo, soap and a hairdryer. There is even a communal fridge for guests to chill their drinks. Our lovely hosts also supplied an abundance of information on the local places of interest. Within an easy stroll of the local shops and informal waterside restaurants, this place is perfect."

-Wendy H.

"I was actually in town on business and a friend recommended the Old Carrabelle Hotel. It I was my first time staying in a B&B and I must say it did not disappoint what I felt was a fabulous experience! You felt like you walked in to your own home. You were not constantly being asked is there anything you need, would you like this or that it was managed perfectly because you were left on your own. No pressure to mix and mingle if you weren’t up to. I felt safe and when I went out I had no reason to feel like I had to pack my valuables and take them with me because there was no intrusion into your room! I definitely cannot wait to return!"

-Mishelle C.

"I came to Carrabelle to go fishing and my guide suggested I stay at the Old Carrabelle Hotel. Very comfortable room with a huge bathroom. Place is quiet, clean, and a true hidden gem. I spent 3 nights here and plan to come back in the future. I recommend this place for anyone stopping in Carrabelle."

-John S.

"One of the best hotels I've every stayed at, it was comfortable, clean and very nostalgic. It is set in the heart of town, so you can just walk around town and enjoy it. It was very easy to check in and out."

-Mike D.

"We felt right at home and relaxed quite well in this beautiful quaint old inn. The inn is full of unique character just like this region of Florida. Skip and Kathy were very cordial and generous hosts and we look forward to our next stay."

-Rebecca B.

“We found the place so charming, clean, convenient, and comfortable. We walked everywhere we went.The owners are extremely friendly and accommodating, and we will definitely be back with our dog and boat.”

-Shira W.

"My friends and I made a short trip to Carrabelle, our first time to that area. We stayed at the Winchester Cottage and it was one of the most charming cottages I have ever stayed in. Very cozy and inviting. We spent most of our time at St George on the beach but coming back to the cottage each day was a wonderful way to end our days."

-Laurie B.

"Holy seashells did I love this place! Fantastic stay in a charming hotel. A clean hotel that made me feel very much at home. Innkeeper welcoming, room and old house restored beautifully. I snapped a bunch of pictures of this place. There are only 4-5 rooms total, but it would be awesome to rent this place out for a family reunion or a get-away-weekend with friends."

-Lynn S.